The Lord of The Flies: Personal Reflections If I were among the boys on the island I would vote for Piggy as leader. Although he is not one of the bigger boys, and seems to be put down all the time, I think that he is the smartest. He would be able to think of ways to be saved. The problem with having Piggy chosen as leader is that he is smaller, and is similar to an outcast. His ideas would not be taken seriously because of his age and size. If the bigger boys were to disagree with one of Piggy's ideas, they may take control, and cause corruption among the kids. I